Nature Vs. Nurture
Posted in Random on February 16th, 2010Right now in my Educational Psychology class we’re talking about cognition and brain development. While I find the class itself immensely boring and pointless, (they’re treating the future teachers of America like 4 year olds, and it’s college here!!) they do touch on a few topics worth thought.
Our last class we discussed studies of IQ scores. My IQ score, 146 the last time I took a test,
back in high school. One random fact, people with an IQ of 150 or above tend to have a happier life, better marriage, and job success according to them. I don’t know where they get their studies, so I don’t know how reliable our notes are, but I know they are from some professional source. I think that study is slightly off. I mean, think of all the geniuses that have committed suicide. Surely with so much intelligence, some of those people are doomed to see the pointlessness of life, since many of them have… but whatever. If you’re smart, you might just be happy.
We also looked at childhood development. Different factors were taken into account, starting with prenatal and ending with home life. What was interesting was that adopted children had slightly higher scores than their genetic family, but the difference was only by 15 points. Overall genetics put bounds on how far a child could develop. Also, those after school and extra learning programs were only beneficial when started before birth and continuing till kindergarten. Starting the mothers with prenatal vitamins and teaching them proper care before birth helped the kid develop more. And you know all those “My baby can read” programs? Well, although they give the kid a jump start early on, studies show that by 8th grade that edge is gone, and they are at the same cognitive level as their peers, sometimes even lower! And giving them extra stimulation with classical music and flash cards has little to no impact on their development. So don’t try to overwhelm your baby early on, let them be kids.
Thinking about childhood development makes me think about how I was raised and how I should raise my kids should that day ever come. (I’m still rather squeamish about the thought of something inside of me, so who knows if I’ll ever manage to go through birth!!) My mom emphasized calmness and study. Every day she would sit us down and do puzzles with us. And every night she would tuck us in and ask us to recall what all we did that day. I don’t know if that helped our cognition or not, but I know it made me value studying more later on.
Do you know your IQ score? How did your mother raise you? Did she put any emphasis on prenatal care?





February 16th, 2010 at 7:26 pm
I think that a good reason why some “geniuses” commit suicide is because they have low EQ. Our professor in General Psychology told us that those who have high IQ don’t always have a high EQ, so I think that those who are intelligent aren’t that much on the affectionate side.
February 16th, 2010 at 8:57 pm
I would actually find those classes interesting considering most of my classes were math and science based. I have no idea what my IQ is, but I do know that I was raised to do the best I can and that was valued. It made all the difference. Prenatal care? Yeah right. She was fresh in the country and couldn’t speak English!
February 17th, 2010 at 12:16 am
Well hey!!! It’s been a while since I’ve been to your page, I enjoyed catching up on reading some of your posts! I’m starting to actually use mine again… I’m taking about 50 days off Facebook for Lent and I figured if I update my blog It’ll keep me feeling like someone COULD read about how boring my life is if they wanted to. lol
Hope you’re doing well!!!!
February 18th, 2010 at 3:05 am
I love the nature nurture debate, it always has such interesting things to offer!!
February 18th, 2010 at 6:08 am
I guess those stats are just representing the majority of the population. I mean, how many freakishly genius people are actually out there? 10 or less?
Hmm that’s very interesting. Today in the newspaper I actually read that toddlers who have trouble crawling (at nine months I think) and sitting up right or w/e at an age I can’t seem to remember, have trouble with learning in the future as well as socialising.
I actually don’t know my IQ score :o I should probably test myself. xD
February 18th, 2010 at 6:20 am
Sorry, I was having trouble with the commenting, so I’ll just finish up here ^^
Well my mother raised me with discipline. She used to smack me with wooden spoon/spatula at home when I did something wrong. She also locked me in a shed for a while once. It may sound horrible, but I think if my mother didn’t discipline me like so, I wouldn’t be such a well behaved student at school (I’m not trying to brag here, but I think it’s true.) I think my mother just ate more fish and that sort of thing while she was pregnant.
February 18th, 2010 at 7:07 am
lol I remembered the IQ Tests my Dad and I took online. I cant remember what we got.XD